Focus
The economic effects of migration are increasingly important across many countries. Immigrant labour can affect firm production and productivity. However, while several studies show migration effects on wages and employment, few provide evidence regarding its impact on firms’ production functions. Firms may adopt more capital-intensive production methods following an influx of skilled workers.
We investigate the impact of immigration on firms’ capital deepening (as measured by the capital-to-labour ratio). We study a large and heterogeneous influx of immigrants into Chile between 2015 and 2019, using a matched employer-employee data set of all formal private sector workers.
Contribution
We develop a theoretical framework with a nested constant elasticity of substitution (CES) production function to analyse how firms adjust their use of capital as well as skilled and unskilled labour. This framework accounts for heterogeneous labour skills, capital-skill complementarity and imperfect substitutability between native and immigrant workers. Our paper extends the migration and labour economics literature by providing new insights into how immigration affects firms’ skill-level composition and capital intensity. To our knowledge, we are the first to empirically test the relationship between immigrant skills and capital deepening at the firm level.
Findings
We find a non-linear effect of skilled immigrants on capital accumulation, due to the imperfect substitutability between immigrant and native workers. Our empirical analysis demonstrates that a 1 percentage point increase in the share of skilled immigrants within a firm raises capital per worker by 1 to 2%. This result supports the capital–skill complementarity hypothesis. However, this relationship is non-linear: the effect on capital deepening is positive but declines as the immigrant concentration increases, turning negative when the share of skilled immigrants exceeds approximately 30% of the firm’s total skilled workforce. This non-linear capital–skilled immigrant labour relationship is consistent with imperfect substitutability between immigrant and native workers within the same skill group. This imperfect substitutability may be partly driven by differences in how tasks are allocated to immigrant and native workers within firms.
Abstract
We study the effect of migration on firms’ capital deepening, leveraging a massive influx of immigrant workers with varying skill sets from Venezuela and Haiti in Chile between 2015 and 2019. Using a theoretical framework that allows for differential productivity between native and immigrant workers, we estimate how firm capital responds to increases in the supply of skilled and unskilled workers. Identification relies on the shift-share instrument to estimate firms’ exposure to immigration shocks. We use unique employer-employee data to match worker characteristics, including country of origin and education level, to balance sheet data from firms’ tax returns, providing highly detailed information about the labor composition and capital in the firm that is not available in other contexts. Our findings show that a 1 p.p. increase in the proportion of skilled immigrants relative to total skilled workers in the firm raises firms’ capital per worker by 1 to 2%. The impact of skilled labor on capital deepening is nonlinear and declines as firms’ immigrant concentration increases, consistent with our model’s predictions. This nonlinear relationship is driven by the imperfect substitutability between immigrants and native workers within the same skill group.